What Is a Progressive Tax? Advantages and Disadvantages

What Is a Progressive Tax?

A progressive tax includes a tax charge that will increase (or progresses) as taxable revenue will increase. It imposes a decrease tax charge on low-income earners and the next tax charge on these with the next revenue. That is normally achieved by creating tax brackets that group taxpayers by revenue ranges.

The revenue tax system within the U.S. is taken into account a progressive system, though it has been rising flatter in latest many years. For 2022 and 2023, there are seven tax brackets with charges of 10%, 12%, 22%, 24%, 32%, 35%, and 37%. There have been 16 tax brackets in 1985.

Key Takeaways

  • A progressive tax imposes the next tax charge on increased taxable incomes than decrease ones.
  • A regressive tax takes a bigger proportion of revenue from low-income people than from these with excessive revenue.
  • A gross sales tax is an instance of a regressive tax.
  • A flat tax is a single revenue tax charge that applies to all taxable revenue, regardless of how a lot or how little.
  • The U.S. Social Safety payroll tax is taken into account a flat tax (with an revenue cap).

Understanding the Progressive Tax

The rationale for a progressive tax is {that a} flat proportion tax can be a disproportionate burden for folks with low incomes. The greenback quantity owed could also be smaller, however the impact on their actual spending energy is bigger.

The diploma to how progressive a tax construction is relies upon upon how a lot of the tax burden is transferred to increased incomes. If one tax code has a low charge of 10% and a excessive charge of 30%, and one other tax code has tax charges starting from 10% to 80%, the latter is extra progressive.

Benefits of a Progressive Tax

On the professional facet, a progressive tax system reduces the tax burden on the individuals who can least afford to pay. That leaves extra money within the pockets of low-wage earners, who’re prone to spend extra of it on important items and stimulate the economic system within the course of.

A progressive tax system additionally tends to gather extra taxes than flat taxes or regressive taxes, as the best proportion of taxes is collected from these with the best quantities of cash.

A progressive tax additionally ends in these with the best quantity of sources funding a better portion of the companies that every one residents and companies depend on, resembling highway upkeep and public security.

Disadvantages of a Progressive Tax

Critics of progressive taxes think about them to be a disincentive to success. Additionally they oppose the system as a method of revenue redistribution, which they imagine punishes the rich, higher class, and even the center class, unfairly.

Opponents of the progressive tax usually are supporters of low taxes and correspondingly minimal authorities companies.

Progressive Tax vs. Regressive Tax

The alternative of a progressive tax, a regressive tax takes a bigger chunk of disposable revenue from low-wage earners than from high-wage earners.

A gross sales tax is an instance of a regressive tax. If two people, one wealthy and one poor, each purchase an an identical bag of groceries, each pay the identical quantity of gross sales tax. However the poorer individual has shelled out a better proportion of their revenue with a purpose to buy these groceries.

Progressive Tax vs. Flat Tax

A flat revenue tax system imposes the identical proportion tax charge on everybody, no matter revenue. Within the U.S., the payroll tax that funds Social Safety and Medicare is commonly thought-about a flat tax as a result of all wage earners pay the identical proportion. Nonetheless, for Social Safety, this tax has a cap.

For 2022, the Social Safety payroll tax is utilized solely to earnings as much as $147,000. For 2023, that determine is $160,200. That makes it a flat tax on everybody, as much as these ranges.

The Medicare tax applies to all lined wages (there isn’t any wage cap as there may be for the Social Safety tax).

Do I Pay the Similar Proportion of Tax on All My Earnings?

No. With a progressive tax, you solely pay your highest proportion on the portion of revenue that exceeds the minimal threshold. For instance, if a single individual makes $100,000 in 2022, they fall into the 24% bracket (in addition to decrease brackets). Nonetheless, solely the portion of their revenue that exceeds the bracket’s minimal threshold of over $89,075 is taxed at that charge. Thus, revenue is taxed at 10% on the primary $10,275, then 12% on revenue as much as $41,775, and 22% on revenue as much as $89,075. On this situation, solely $10,925 ($100,000 – $89,075) can be taxed at 24%.

How Typically Do the Tax Brackets Change?

Tax brackets are set by Congress and enforced by the Inner Income Service (IRS). Modifications sometimes come within the type of laws just like the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017, which saved seven brackets however lowered the charges that utilized to virtually each one.

What Is the Goal of a Progressive Tax?

Progressive taxes exist in order that the burden of paying for presidency companies, oversight, and infrastructure does not fall disproportionately on these incomes decrease incomes. With a progressive tax system, those that earn much less are taxed much less. Those that earn extra are taxed extra. For the reason that prime earners are taxed extra and on bigger sums of cash, a progressive tax additionally will increase the quantity of tax income coming in.

The Backside Line

A progressive tax is a tax that progresses to increased tax charges as taxable revenue will increase. It implies that these people with low incomes are taxed at decrease charges than people with increased incomes.

The U.S. progressive revenue tax includes tax brackets, every with its personal tax charge. For tax years 2022 and 2023, these tax charges are 10%, 12%, 22%, 24%, 32%, 35%, and 37%. Whereas the tax charges did not change from 2022 to 2023, the vary of revenue lined by every bracket elevated to replicate inflation.

See also  Major Players in the 2008 Financial Crisis: Where Are They Now?