Stunned Bar Owner Recalls Delphi Murder Suspect Sitting Inches Away From ‘Wanted’ Sketch
Trying again on it now, Bob Matlock can’t imagine the suspect was sitting proper in entrance of him all alongside.
Accused double assassin and CVS pharmacy technician Richard Allen, a 50-year-old father of two charged with killing Delphi, Indiana teenagers Libby German and Abby Williams on a climbing path in 2017, was a daily buyer at Matlock’s tavern, JC’s Bar.
“He would are available and we might at all times speak concerning the women and all the things,” Matlock, 75, advised The Each day Beast on Monday. “We’d keep it up conversations about it, he would say, you understand, it’s such a tragedy, and we’d say we felt sorry for the households and all that, however we tried to not speak about it an excessive amount of as a result of all of us knew the households, and have been pals with the households.”
Matlock, who owned JC’s from 2005 till it was shuttered in December 2021, stated he has thought of Allen and his spouse Kathy “good pals” for practically 20 years. The couple have been members of the bar’s pool league, and have been lively in the area people, based on Matlock, who stated he frolicked with them not solely at JC’s however exterior of labor, as effectively. He insisted there “was by no means any indication” that Allen, identified to his pals as Rick, would later be implicated within the twin killings that shocked the small Midwestern city.
“I simply couldn’t imagine it once they stated they arrested him,” stated Matlock. “I stated, ‘Nicely, that may’t be the Rick we all know.’ After which we come to search out out it was… There wouldn’t have been any inkling to anybody that knew him that may count on him to do one thing like that. He simply didn’t appear that sort of particular person. However… you by no means know.”
In a darkish twist, Allen posed for {a photograph} one night in JC’s close to a police sketch—meant to be a rendering of Allen’s personal face—hanging on the wall behind him. Looking back, Matlock doesn’t assume the depiction was correct in any respect.
A police sketch of Allen on the wall could be seen simply over his proper shoulder.
Fb/JC’s Bar
“We have been all sitting on the desk there, we have been having a pool evening, and simply having enjoyable—we have been snapping photos and all the things,” Matlock recalled. “Each enterprise on the town had these [sketches] up. It simply occurred to be, he was sitting there on the time. However to me, that didn’t resemble Rick… My different patrons round city [would] are available for breakfast or lunch, all people would say, ‘Christ, that don’t seem like anyone,’ or, ‘It could possibly be anyone.’”
Libby and Abby disappeared the day earlier than Valentine’s Day 2017. The 2 had gone out for a stroll and by no means returned, prompting a large search that evening. The women’ our bodies have been discovered the following day, close to a creek.
Libby’s grandmother, Becky Patty, advised The Each day Beast final December that the household’s lives had “been on maintain for 5 years.” In 2019, Indiana State Police Superintendent Doug Carter stated police believed the suspect was “from Delphi—at present or has beforehand lived right here, visits Delphi regularly or works right here.”
Investigators found a quick video on Libby’s cellphone which was taken the day she and Abby vanished. The grainy footage appeared to point out a person strolling on a slender bridge close to the place the women had been final seen. In audio launched by police, the suspect could be heard saying, “Down the hill.”
“To me, even the voice… I didn’t assume that resembled Rick’s voice,” stated Matlock. “All people listened to all this, as a result of all people was .”
However Allen continued hiding in plain sight, even going out of his method to seem empathetic with considered one of his alleged victims’ households.
Becky Patty and Libby’s grandfather Mike told reporters on Monday that Allen didn’t cost them to print funeral images of the 2 women once they introduced them into CVS for processing.
In an e-mail, a CVS spokesperson advised The Each day Beast, “As members of the Carroll County group, we stay devastated by these murders and our hearts exit to the German and Williams households. We’re shocked and saddened to study that considered one of our retailer workers was arrested as a suspect in these crimes. We stand able to cooperate with the police investigation in any approach we are able to.”
Because the investigation wore on, Matlock and his employees would carry meals to a close-by police station the place detectives have been working late to unravel the murders. He and all the JC’s regulars have been keenly conscious of developments within the case as they occurred, since everybody in Delphi was ready for solutions.
Allen was a “quiet man,” and at all times “so pleasant,” Matlock stated. He stated Allen’s spouse was “so candy” and works for a veterinarian.
Kathy Allen was unable to be reached for touch upon Monday.
There have been quite a few individuals of curiosity probed by cops through the years, together with a 27-year-old Peru, Indiana resident named Kegan Anthony Kline. Kline, who’s awaiting trial on a slew of prices together with youngster solicitation, youngster exploitation, possession of kid pornography, identification fraud, and obstruction of justice, allegedly confessed to having communicated with underage women on social media, reportedly receiving greater than 100 specific images and movies from them.
Police searched Kline’s residence 11 days after Libby and Abby went lacking. Nevertheless, he has not up to now been linked on to their murders.
At a press convention earlier Monday, Carter known as Allen’s arrest “a significant step in resulting in a conclusion of this long-term and complicated investigation,” however declined to supply additional particulars concerning the proof that lastly led to Allen’s arrest. A possible trigger affidavit within the case is sealed till additional discover.
“I’m completely in shock that it’s Rick,” Matlock stated. “There’s acquired to be one thing [there], or else they wouldn’t have arrested him. Till I hear precisely what they’ve, I am simply going to roll with it.”
Allen’s trial date has been set for March 20, 2023. The investigation, based on Carter, continues.
—with further reporting by Pilar Melendez
Learn extra at The Each day Beast.
Get the Each day Beast’s greatest scoops and scandals delivered proper to your inbox. Enroll now.
Keep knowledgeable and achieve limitless entry to the Each day Beast’s unmatched reporting. Subscribe now.
